The Exchange: Bitcoin Finds a Price

On Sunday, in the middle of a quiet July, a programmer who had never met the inventor of Bitcoin launched the first real market for the digital currency, and almost no one noticed. The programmer, Jed McCaleb, built the exchange in a weekend after reading about Bitcoin on Slashdot, and the exchange was called Mt. Gox, a name carried over from his earlier project, the Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange. The exchange is the July 2010 story, and the story is the lesson: the ideas that change the world often begin as weekend projects, crude and unnoticed, built by people the world has never heard of.

The Exchange is the subject of this article: what Mt. Gox was, why the moment mattered, how a price appeared where none had existed, and why the timing was no accident. The exchange opened on July 18, and the story of the weeks since is just beginning. This is the story of the exchange, and the story is about the moment a currency without a government found a price.

1. The Launch

The launch was a weekend project, and the project was the beginning. Jed McCaleb was a programmer known for eDonkey, the file-sharing network, and he had read about Bitcoin on Slashdot and been intrigued. He built the exchange in a weekend, and the exchange opened on July 18, 2010. The first trades were a few bitcoins for fractions of a cent, and the fractions were the start.

The name was the quirk. Mt. Gox stood for the Magic: The Gathering Online Exchange, the card-trading project that had come before, and the name stuck to the new project like a joke that turned out to be history. The exchange was named after a card game, the builder was a file-sharing programmer, and the currency had no government behind it. The oddity was the whole story, and the story was just beginning.

2. The State

The state of Bitcoin in July 2010 was a state of almost nothing. The network had run since January 2009, when the genesis block was mined, and the coins were dug out of the code by hobbyists running their home computers. There was no real price, because there was no real market. The closest thing to a price was a calculation posted in October 2009 by a site called New Liberty Standard, which worked out that one dollar equaled about 1,309 bitcoins, and the calculation was an estimate, not a market.

The trades happened by hand. People who wanted bitcoins found each other on forums and agreed on numbers in comment threads, and the most famous trade of the era had happened in May, when a programmer paid 10,000 bitcoins for two pizzas. The pizzas were the joke of the community, and the joke was the point: the coins were worth whatever two people agreed they were worth, one comment at a time.

3. The Gap

The gap was the missing piece, and the missing piece was the price. Bitcoin had scarcity, security, and a growing band of enthusiasts, but it had no way for buyers and sellers to meet in one place and discover what a coin was worth. The forum threads were slow, the deals were private, and the value of the currency was whatever a stranger would offer in a comment. The currency had no market, and the market was the thing it needed most.

The gap was also the opportunity, and the opportunity was the exchange. A currency without a market is a hobby; a currency with a market is an asset. The step between the two was a simple piece of software, a place where bids met asks, and the software was the missing bridge. The bridge was waiting to be built, and the builder was about to appear.

4. The Market

The market was the machine, and the machine was simple. Mt. Gox took the handshake out of the forum and put it into an order book: buyers posted bids, sellers posted asks, and the exchange matched them. For the first time, anyone could see what people were willing to pay for a bitcoin, in dollars, in real time. The price was no longer a comment; the price was a number on a screen.

The market was also the change of kind. A hobby is a thing you do; a market is a thing you watch, and trade, and think about. The exchange turned Bitcoin from an experiment for enthusiasts into a tradeable asset, and the turning was the transformation. The coins were the same, the network was the same, and everything was different, because now there was a price.

5. The Price

The price was the surprise, and the surprise was the speed. The first trades were fractions of a cent, and within weeks the price had multiplied about tenfold, from a fraction of a cent to roughly eight cents, in the space of a single month. The rise was tiny by the standards of any real market, and the tiny rise was the first proof that the currency could hold value in the eyes of strangers.

The price was the message, and the message was the interest. The hobbyists who had mined coins on their home computers were watching their holdings become worth something, and the people who had first heard about Bitcoin on Slashdot were finding a place to buy in. The bids and asks were votes, and the votes were adding up. The price was the beginning of the market, and the beginning was the point.

6. The Man

The man was the exchange, and the exchange was one man. Jed McCaleb ran Mt. Gox alone, a single programmer keeping a market alive on his own, and the aloneness was the scale of the thing. He had built the exchange in a weekend, and he ran it the same way, without a company, without employees, without the machinery that surrounded real exchanges. The exchange was crude, and the crudeness was the honesty of the moment: a market built by one curious person, for a currency that had never had one.

The man was also the pattern. The story of Bitcoin so far had been the story of amateurs: the inventor was anonymous, the miners were hobbyists, the trades were forum comments, and the exchange was a weekend project. The pattern was the point. The currency was being built by people who built it because they wanted to, and the wanting was the energy. The exchange was the latest and largest of the amateur works, and the works were adding up to something.

7. The Meaning

The meaning was the question underneath, and the question was the money. Bitcoin was a currency with no government behind it, no bank to print it, no central bank to defend it, and the question had always been whether such a thing could have a value that anyone trusted. The exchange was the beginning of an answer, and the beginning was the market. The bids and asks were votes, and the votes were the trust, and the trust was the price.

The meaning was also the moment. Two years after the financial crisis, which had shown what happened when trust in the old money failed, here was a currency that did not ask for trust in any institution at all, a currency whose value would be whatever its users agreed it was, and now it had a place where the agreement could happen. The exchange was small, the price was tiny, and the idea was enormous: the first steps of a market for a currency with no government behind it.

8. The Lesson

The lesson of the exchange was about the smallness of beginnings, and the smallness was the power. The market for Bitcoin began as a weekend project by a file-sharing programmer, named after a card game, trading fractions of a cent, and the smallness was the truth of how the world changes. The great things do not arrive with announcements; they arrive quietly, built by one person in a weekend, and they grow because people find them useful. The exchange is the July 2010 story, and the story is the lesson: the ideas that change the world often begin as the smallest things, unnoticed, undervalued, and just beginning to find a price.

The lesson was also about the price itself. For almost two years, Bitcoin had been a currency without a number, a thing whose value lived in forum comments and pizza jokes. The exchange gave it a number, and the number was the beginning of the market, and the market was the beginning of the trust, and the trust was the beginning of everything that could come next. The exchange was crude, the builder was alone, and none of the risks were visible yet, because the moment was not about the risks. The moment was about the first step, and the first step was the price. The weeks ahead would show whether the buyers would stay, whether the price would hold, and the showing was the test. The exchange was the seed, and the seed was planted. The question was not whether the currency was radical, and the question was whether the radical currency could find a price that held, and the finding would be the story of the years to come. The exchange is the beginning of the story, and the beginning is the point of this article. The market was not new in every part: exchanges had matched buyers and sellers for centuries, and the matching was the oldest trick in commerce. The newness was the subject: a currency with no government, no bank, and no promises, discovering what it was worth in the most ordinary way possible, one bid and one ask at a time. The readers who watched the numbers climb understood what they were seeing, and what they were seeing was the design of an alternative.

Tags

#technology #business